What types of tapes are you using? How much space are your differential backups taking at the moment? Remember, a differential backup only backs up the changes since the last full backup, while incrementals backup the changes since the last backup. A full backup is usually taken every weekend, so the differentials or incrementals are done the other 4,5 or 6 days of the week, depending on your working days (normally 4 diff and 1 full backup would be the standard). In most cases an incremental backup will hardly scrape the beginning of a tape, and 4 incremental backups would be equal to the last differential backup you'd do during a week, and this would still fit snugly to the first half of the tape. So I don't think you'd need more tapes whether you backup differentials or incrementals. Also the time used would still fit easily.
Only if you have a huge number of changes done to your files every day would that be a problem.