Thanks PCBonez,
I seemed to have everything ok... till I installed the Logitech webcam...
Then I got an ati2dvag stop EA BSOD...
I have admittted defeat and am now part way through a clean install of XP.
I have XP SP3, all the previous drivers I was using AND the logitech Webcam... all working... no random ati errors or BSOD.
I guess we will never know what combination of updates, drivers and bad luck caused the original problem...
My advice if you get this... look to reinstall XP or migrate to Linux
This problem can be closed as unresolved.